August 10, 2007

Oliver Twist (2005)

3/5

Roman Polanski's version of the Dickens classic does not stand out in any way except visually, and not in an altogether positive way. The choice of which plot elements of the story would appear was kept to a minimum and included only the already famous "essential" scenes of the story. Although he did give slightly more depth to each scene, Polanski added nothing of his own directorial style, which made for a very uninteresting movie. We already know everything, so why are we watching? The film's colors are much too warm and inviting for the bleak and depressing environment of a traditional Dickens interpretation, as in the Lean adaptation. The acting, while acceptable, was hidden beneath layers of heavy make-up and exaggerated caricatures that made any emotional involvement with the characters impossible. The plot seems to progress by adding more and more characters instead of fleshing out and maturing old ones, and it becomes less and less about Oliver Twist the character and more about him as an object to own and use. And Barney Clark's Oliver just didn't garner much sympathy from me, I don't know what it was.

There were some positive attributes to the movie. The set design, costuming, and make-up was absolutely amazing. It was an exemplary achievement and a breathtaking spectacle to behold. Also, the music was really good, epic with just the right touch of melodrama. There were three excellent mini-scenes that really stood out and gave the movie a bit more visual flair than the otherwise boring and mundane shot/counter-shot staple. The pacing was precise, with nothing lingered on too profoundly. And while this review is mostly negative, nothing about the movie was appallingly bad. It just didn't live up to expectations, and nothing about it really warranted a remake. But I would say see it if you have no idea who Oliver Twist is! Which is nobody reading my reviews, I hope.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0380599/

The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993)

4/5

The Nightmare Before Christmas follows Jack Skellington, who gets bored of being the Pumpkin King of Halloween Town and, upon accidentally visiting Christmas Town, decides he wants to bring a special kind of Christmas to Christmas Town. It is a simple story told efficiently and skillfully. The animation is absolutely beautiful to behold. The music was energetic and exciting; it draws you in perhaps more than the story itself does. The environment of these worlds is expertly evoked and cleverly detailed. Most of the story was unpredictable and really engaged me because I had no idea what kind of world this was, what special rules they followed, and how all the events would play out. Also, I loved the climactic fight at the end.

I thought Jack's change of character at the end felt out of place; there wasn't any real explanation for it and it didn't follow any legitimate train of thought. I thought the love story was too simple to be believable. These elements felt like they were included because of some arbitrary requirement from a scriptwriting class, not because they fit the story. I loved the creepy atmosphere, but felt it didn't quite mix with the fun, musical style. It was sort of a kid's movie made for adults, too goofy for adults and too scary for kids. Highly recommended, but only for a specific target audience.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0107688/

August 09, 2007

Jacob's Ladder (1990)

3/5

Jacob's Ladder isn't really a horror movie, as I initially thought it was, but in fact an intense psychological exploration of hallucinatory paranoia. Jacob Singer, a Vietnam vet deftly and believably played by Tim Robbins, starts having nightmares about a specific attack his unit experienced back in the Mekong Delta. The movie takes you along effortlessly in revealing the events that happened and his resulting descent into madness. The bizarre images were evocative and unsettling, although not quite shocking or frightening. I liked how the movie pushes and pulls you at will, convincing you of one reality before tearing it all down and putting you into another. The movie was always interesting, its pacing and progression perfect. The cinematography was above average at times, merely average at others. The editing was also quite good, extremely fluid except for a few spots that lingered too long.

Much of the movie feels dated, from the characters' hairstyles to the music and dancing. Many hallucinations really did not fit at all (the demon dancing/fondling, or whatever it was) or served absolutely no purpose (the car chase). The scarier parts instead are based in some form of recognizable reality (putting him in an ice bath because of his high fever). Most of the supporting acting was sub-par and/or throwaway (except for Danny Aiello, who was incredibly and surprisingly tender). Also, yes, Jason Alexander was in the film, but his involvement actually hurt the movie overall because I could not separate his George from Seinfeld with his role in this. Also, I found the plot quite predictable and unimaginative. And what is up with the gratuitous nudity? I say, there's no need to go out of your way to see this movie. But if you like Tim Robbins, it won't hurt to stick this in your DVD player.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0099871/

August 08, 2007

I Confess (1953)

4/5

I Confess is a wonderful lost gem from Hitchcock's oeuvre. A priest (Montgomery Clift) is falsely accused of murder and, despite knowing who the real murderer is, he decides to keep silent because it was revealed to him during confession. In typical Hitchcock style, the composition and camerawork were excellent, but the complex and realistic characters were the best part of this movie. Much like Casablanca, the audience's emotional attachment to each character shifts throughout the film, switching back and forth between love and hate as information is gradually revealed. I loved how seemingly minor characters (such as Keller's wife) emerge as being vital to the plot, tension, and even message. The acting by all parties was very good overall, although at times a bit too exaggerated. While the story plodded along in the middle (and was interesting although not particularly suspenseful), the thrilling finale was especially brilliant. It went deeper into the consequences of the characters' actions than you thought it would, and the characters themselves feel much fuller and richer as their motivations and regrets (or lack thereof) are further revealed.

I felt that some of this movie was below average and could have been heavily improved upon. The script had some problems, not in dialogue, but in overall structure. The heavy use of flashback in Anne Baxter's interrogation, coupled with its clunky style and lack of rhythm, simply did not work. The trial could have and should have been made more compelling; it seemed as if there was no climax here, merely a playing out of events. And while the score by Dimitri Tiomkin wasn't bad, it has nothing on the perfectly seamless integration Hitchcock usually has with Bernard Herrmann. I also have no idea why the film was set in Quebec; it just seemed odd. The rest, though, is an unexpected joy to behold, and is highly recommended.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0045897/

August 07, 2007

Irreversible (2002)

3/5

Despite its title, Irreversible is told entirely in reverse. A violent act of revenge preceded by a vicious rape and the events that led up to it. This movie is not for the faint of heart because it is unflinching in its documentation of said brutalities. It is a disquieting tale of things that happen beyond our control and it reaches us because we feel so helpless. We realize that it could be us, no matter how different our lives are, and there is nothing we can do to stop it. Its realistic depiction is aided by single-takes. Its use of music effectively ratchets up the tension and speeds up your pulse. I love a scene near the end, where the two people who become tangled up in violence and rape are instead entwined in each other; evil is replaced by love.

But there is so much to hate about this movie. From beginning to pretentious, baffling, experimental end, the camera rotates and swirls around to a fever pitch. Your stomach literally churns; I could not imagine seeing this in a theater, especially not an IMAX. The camerawork feels like a gimmick to physically make you as sick as the disturbing events do at a mental level later on. There was a decidedly unnecessary and gratuitous amount of nudity, sex, and violence in this movie; some of it was essential, but as a whole it became almost exploitative, as if its extensive presence had the sole purpose of shocking the audience.

I don't think the reverse chronology worked for this movie. Much like 21 Grams, it diluted the emotional build-up and climax and the film lost a lot of its overall impact. One of the main character's shift in demeanor, when told backwards, almost feels like a devolution; you like him much less. And the end extends for far too long. The problem with most movies that go backwards is that you never really reach a point where it makes sense to stop. Normal movies reach a climax and then tie up loose ends, but where do you go once you've told the start of a story? The intro is almost never as compelling as the finale, and it isn't in this movie either. Some of the dialogue that would have worked in a normal chronology seems contrived and forced when told backwards (about events being decided beforehand and having no control over them, for example). The backwards time line did have one good aspect, however. You saw the act committed first, and then you see all the parts of the story in which one different word, one different action, one different choice could have prevented all this. It becomes so much more painful.

Despite my rating, I cannot make a blanket recommendation of this movie to anyone. You have to know what to expect and have to be ready to take it all in. It is hard to digest, but not without merit.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0290673/

August 06, 2007

The Ninth Gate (1999)

2/5

The Ninth Gate follows Johnny Depp as he travels around Europe trying to authenticate a rare text believed to be able to conjure up the devil. Yes, it does sound a little similar to Indiana Jones, but it doesn't play like that awesome adventure series. Instead, this piece of crap is filled with predictable subplots, hollow characters, boring action, unexplained scenes, bland cinematography, uninspired editing, unnecessary nudity, and mediocre acting. It is, in a word, bad. But in truth, as I was watching it, I was entertained. It was always pretty interesting and enjoyable. I kept waiting for an explanation, and the fact that none came only disappointed me at the end of the movie, not during! Also, there were some pretty funny parts (some unintentional). Save yourself the trouble of watching this movie because, though it may look interesting, you will get nothing out of it except exasperation.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0142688/

August 05, 2007

Death and the Maiden (1994)

3/5

Death and the Maiden is a psychological thriller from director Roman Polanski about a woman (Sigourney Weaver) who believes that a man her husband brings home one night (Ben Kingsley) was a key member in her torture years earlier. She ties him up and tortures him so that he will confess to what he's done. But did he really do it? So begins a tense night, where secrets are revealed from all three of the main characters. The plot progression was fantastic; we slowly learn of each person's history and motivations in very calculated amounts. Kingsley's acting was superb. Until the end, we could never be certain whether he did it or not. He reveals nothing despite being on screen almost the entire movie. Most of Weaver's acting was also great, but was marred by the occasional ludicrous piece of dialogue or ludicrous delivery of an otherwise normal line. The descriptions of torture were hard to bear sometimes, but essential because it gave the audience a glimpse into what she had been through. The music was great as well (Schubert's Death and the Maiden, from which this movie gets its title).

Sigourney Weaver was naked for a period of time in the beginning of the movie. It was both unnecessary and unwanted. Because she looks like a man--an ugly man. The first half hour or so felt really wobbly; you could tell how Polanski tried to force tension on the audience to keep us interested as he set the scene for the rest of the movie. The story often went off on tangents (the husband sleeping with another woman) that would neither relate back to the central plot nor increase the tension. So why were they included at all? Sometimes characters would act in extreme and unrealistic ways, and others would consequently react to those actions unrealistically as well. The ending felt like a cop-out to me because everything was tied up a little too neatly. Both the cinematography and editing were unexceptional, except for several shots that made excellent use of foreground and background to increase the tension. I really did enjoy this movie though, and recommend it if you like psychological thrillers and/or Polanski.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0109579/

I Stand Alone (1998)

4.9/5

Gaspar Noé's I Stand Alone is a brutal film, on par with or even exceeding Requiem for a Dream in its utter hopelessness and unrelentingly bleak outlook on life. This film is extremely unsettling; it instantly gets under your skin and stays with you long after the film ends. The story is closer to that of Taxi Driver, as a delusional butcher slowly goes insane and his fantasies turn violent. His twisted sense of love, justice, and morality is such an extreme perversion that you really have no idea what he is capable of. But like A Clockwork Orange, this film forces you to empathize with him by using ubiquitous voice-over narration of his innermost private thoughts. Despite wanting to look away in horror and revulsion, your eyes are glued to the screen. The shot compositions tend to avoid showing faces or eyes, focusing instead on the bodies or the mouth, emphasizing the butcher's distorted perceptions. The editing is punctuated by a singular music note or by a gunshot; it is always unexpected and always makes you jump. I found the most terrifying part to simply be the following words: "Warning: You have 30 seconds to leave the screening of this film." After seeing the graphic violence and sex that had come before without any such warning, I was almost trembling with fear as my mind raced through all the possibilities of what could happen. And the climax was absolutely torrential. Perhaps the most twisted part of this movie is that it pretends to give you a happy ending--but that is only the butcher's point of view.

This movie represents excellent, effective filmmaking, but is not without flaws. I thought the film lost a lot of steam during the middle thirty minutes, although it brought it back in full force and then some after that lull. Some of the sex scenes early on were unnecessary. (We get that he's watching a porno--we don't also need to be watching it, do we?) I think that an unbelievable amount of political and social commentary went over my head simply because of the intensity of the performances and the vulgarity of the events--there was just too much to focus on all at once. Also, being told entirely from one deranged person's mind, such commentary is inherently biased and as such loses some value. Even with these mistakes, I see a master filmmaker honing his craft, unafraid to immerse himself in realms few have dared even peer into.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0157016/

August 04, 2007

Seconds (1966)

2/5

Seconds follows aging Arthur Hamilton, who is selected to have his death faked and undergo surgery so that he can start a new life. It is in fact a rather bland drama masquerading as a thriller. Neither genre works, moving back and forth between the two with no central mood, build-up, or connection. It was interesting to see how this film connected them, but the final product just doesn't work. The drama portion is the most compelling part because the suspense aspect simply does not succeed, despite being directed by Frankenheimer (he previously directed the brilliant original version of The Manchurian Candidate). The drama hit me hard despite its lack of originality, mostly because I was expecting a traditional thriller and was surprised to see its presence in the movie at all. It deals with the age-old question of the meaning of life, the choices we make, and the mistakes we must live with. But it's not worth sitting through the entire movie just to get that little out of it. Instead, go out and rent It's A Wonderful Life because it deals with the same questions more thoroughly and honestly--not to mention that it's more tense because you come to really care for Jimmy Stewart's character as he contemplates suicide.

The acting felt hollow, except for John Randolph and Rock Hudson, who really owned their parts. Most of the cinematography was distracting (especially the distorted, close-up hand-held shots) except for a very few interesting and effective ones. The editing confused instead of clarified, and it tried too hard. There was a lengthy bacchanalia sequence that felt out of place and exploitative. There are so many characters and events that are simply a waste of time; I felt cheated out of an hour of my life, as this movie could've been made much tighter and better in 45 minutes. Plot points were intentionally left muddy and unexplained. I did get something out of the movie, but not anything that would have taken 105 minutes on my own. Don't bother with this movie.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0060955/

August 03, 2007

The Tenant (1976)

4/5

Polanski's The Tenant follows Trelkovsky (played by Polanski himself) as he rents an apartment where the previous tenant committed suicide. Gradually, he begins to think that his neighbors are trying to turn him into the last tenant so that he too will kill himself. It is brilliantly suspenseful and psychologically terrifying as it crescendos to the shocking climax. And it is a refreshing treat after seeing Knife in the Water and Repulsion. He seems to have discovered cinematography, as we finally get shots where we can tell what's going on, thanks to the great Sven Nykvist. There are also some masterful camera movements and envious tracking shots (the camera once goes through a stairway railing, for example). I really liked the acting in this movie--Polanski knows what he's doing as an actor just as much as a director. Is is truly horrifying to see him not only inhabit the previous tenant's apartment, but also inherit her habits and friends. Subtly at first, then flamboyantly. The build-up works extremely well as it keeps your heart pounding ever harder, whether through anxious waiting or sexual tension. I absolutely loved the ending.

There were some problems with it as well. The first half and second half don't seem to mesh very well, almost as if they were two separate movies. The first half was a psychological thriller and the second half was a horror movie. The divide was really striking and much too sudden, taking away from my overall enjoyment. For some reason, some of the audio felt like it was dubbed over. Was English the original audio track language? I don't know. Also, there were so many side stories that neither advanced the plot nor increased the tension (like getting hit by the car and Stella's party).

This is definitely a movie other film fans will appreciate. I can see the inspirations for The Shining with the haunting imagery. Early in the movie, Trelkovsky finds a hole in the wall covered up with a cotton ball, behind which is a human tooth. Repeatedly, tenants stand in the bathroom staring up into Trelkovsky's room, keeping deathly still. And he borrows heavily from Hitchcock's best works: the doubling of elements and people in Vertigo, the voyeuristic viewing of neighbors in Rear Window, and the cross-dressing and split-personality in Psycho. I think most cinephiles will appreciate this movie based on those credentials, but if it sounds interesting and you like Polanski, this is definitely one to check out.

IMDb link: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0074811/