July 15, 2007

The Black Dahlia (2006)

2/5

The Black Dahlia is a completely fictionalized detective story set in the 40's about the real-life murder and dismemberment of Elizabeth Short. Based on a novel by James Ellroy (L.A. Confidential) and directed by Brian De Palma, I was pretty excited when I first found out about it, and pretty disappointed to hear all the terrible reviews. But I gave it a chance anyway, which was unfortunate. This movie is not very good. The problem with this movie was not that it was too confusing, but that it just didn't make any sense. The characters' motivations and actions were out of the blue and absolutely ludicrous sometimes. Everything was so exaggerated. The plot of the first half feels random and unnecessary, only for the second half to reveal that all these coincidences and side stories were vitally important. Most important-looking characters ended up being superfluous and most forgettable ones turned up again at the end. It somewhat cheapens the whole thing. The dialogue tried too hard and fell flat. It was often hard to hear what people were saying, or divine the meaning behind their words. The characters were unconvincing and felt really out of place in the environment, although I did like the acting. I particularly hated the echoing voices of people remembering important things that others had said.

The cinematography, set design, and costumes worked really great. There was one really slick sequence where Johansson's character sees Hartnett's character with another woman that I thought was done exceptionally well. Some of the fighting was cool, although it was mostly in the beginning. The music really wasn't bad at all and the editing was at least undistracting and competent. At least most of the movie was pretty interesting, despite not really knowing what was going on. All in all, very highly unrecommended whether you're interested in it or not (although it wasn't as terrible as my extremely low expectations).

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0387877/

Miller's Crossing (1990)

4.9/5

Miller's Crossing is exquisitely detailed, exceedingly complex, and fully realized from start to finish. Darkly comic, this crime movie set in the Prohibition-era 30's tries to be a film noir in dialogue and a gangster movie a la The Godfather in content. Instead of fitting well into either category, it ends up being a fresh blend of both. Filled with double crosses, hidden agendas, and snappy dialogue, the plot can get quite confusing at times, but never out of reach for the attentive viewer. It envelops you in its own world, where every word has meaning if you know how to hear it right. The atmosphere is so real you're breathing the same air they are. My favorite aspect of this movie, and what keeps me coming back for more, is the abundance of subtle nuances left in the background for the especially watchful to pick up on. While the movie does explain the main story, it leaves a lot of important side stories and relationships open for the audience to chew over and realize on their own, which makes it much more engaging and memorable for those watching.

Onto the technical specifics. The acting was unerringly precise from all parties. The editing was terrific, milking every shot and scene for all they're worth while still maintaining mood and environment. The script itself is so rich and multi-layered in plot alone that it could stand up to analysis from a dozen different angles and produce different results each time. The dialogue is pithy and smart, as only the Coens know how to make it, although it does sometimes feel a bit "written." And it requires a very sensitive ear and very active mind to pick up on everything.

I remembered it being prettier, and was a little disappointed seeing it again and noticing rather bland colors and flat shots. While brilliant in composition and framing, the actual execution itself was not up to my expectations. The sound design as well made it a bit difficult to hear what the characters were saying, although perhaps the accents and word choice added to that problem. The dialogue doesn't quite succeed as a 40's noir, but the fervent and dedicated attempt more than make up for it. The music felt extremely out of place, specifically the choice of the main theme and also the times at which it would crop up, almost as if by accident. Also, some of the violence was a bit too exaggerated and almost laughable, although I'm pretty sure it's intentional. Very highly recommended, for any Coen brothers fan, Byrne fan, or gangster/noir fan. I will leave you with my two favorite lines from the movie.

"Nobody knows anybody. Not that well."

--"Look in your heart, look in your heart!"
--"What heart?"

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0100150/

Knocked Up (2006)

4.9/5

Knocked Up is an incredibly hilarious movie about a one-night stand that turns into a pregnancy. From a simple story comes incredibly rich and developed characters and healthy doses of humor and heart. You go to see this movie for the jokes (and I was laughing the entire time), but the staying power rests in the deeper meaning and take-home message about life and love. Unlike other comedies like Hot Fuzz, when this movie tries to make a dramatic point, it feels like part of the movie and not a side note. The flow in this movie as the mood shifts gears is fantastic, aided by excellent music choices. My favorite parts were when people were arguing, because it seemed like that's when the characters were most themselves and the details and subtle mannerisms showed. That was also when I laughed the hardest. The writing in this movie was not exactly brilliant or original, but the stellar acting brought it to life. Being a fan of The Office, I especially loved seeing Darryl from warehouse, Ryan the temp, and Steve Carell make cameos. And Alan Tudyk from Firefly. I especially loved all the references to other movies, not just in dialogue and background sets, but also in plot and shot constructions.

There were some things I didn't like about the movie, although infrequent. First, much of it was simply too graphic. Random boobs were wholly unnecessary. And why they showed a newborn crowning is a mystery to me. A bit out of place in this comedy. Second, many of the side characters and side plots, while very funny, simply took away from the movie instead of adding to it, except in length. Sometimes characters' moods and motivations shifted and changed with little explanation, although it was never too unreasonable. Every so often something you thought was small would turn out to be extremely important and vice versa, which sometimes felt like forcing the plot in a certain direction in an otherwise fluid script. Also, the cinematography and editing were nothing to write home about, not that you would think they might be. All in all, however, a very entertaining movie that's more than just a stupid comedy.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0478311/

July 13, 2007

Zodiac (2007)

4/5

Zodiac is a 2 hour and 40 minute epic about the real-life unsolved case of a serial killer terrorizing the California community in the late 60's and early 70's, the media sensation covering it, and one cartoonist's obsession with it. Fincher's directing was phenomenal throughout; despite the film's running time, I was tense and terrified the entire time. The acting by all was equally stellar and a real pleasure to watch. The music did a great job at setting and maintaining mood. The cinematography and editing were just as amazing, and probably Fincher's best to date. Eye-catching shots were crisp and clean with a glossy sheen; I loved the silky smooth shadows flowing across people's faces, cars, and houses. The beginning had a lot of unique point-of-view and tracking/following shots, but they were gradually replaced with more traditional shots as the bulk of the content began. This film's greatest strengths are the flawlessly-captured time and place and the thoroughly-detailed characters. And the script was witty and fun.

The biggest detractor from the movie was its length. The movie consists of several main stories that could each have their own film, and if you're not interested in one, that's half the movie that's gonna bore you. None of the stories felt tacked on because they were all given a great amount of depth, but perhaps too much for everyone's tastes. Luckily, I loved all the stories and didn't really mind the length because of the great acting and great directing. The movie needs to decide what it wants to tell and tell that; instead it provides a great many details from a great many number of sources with no main driving force. Characters appear and drop off when the details bring them to the forefront. Many subplots seemed forced, as if every lead in the case and new piece of evidence required a thrilling story to go with it. Also, the movie loses a little steam at around the 2/3 mark, when a typical movie would be approaching its end and this one has none in sight. All in all, however, I highly recommend this film if you are at all interested in detective stories or movies about serial killers. This one is fantastic, and it goes past the surface of a simple story and into the real effects on the lives of those following the case.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0443706/

July 08, 2007

13 Tzameti (2005)

3/5

The plot of 13 Tzameti revolves around a very interesting idea that is carried out very well. A poor immigrant roof worker steals an envelope intended for his recently deceased employer and follows the instructions inside in the hopes of making some money, and from there gets involved in a dark and dangerous "game." I urge you not to see the trailer or read any reviews that give away the plot, because there's not much to the movie other than the rather simple story. But it is a harrowing thriller that keeps you on the edge of your seat for most of the movie. The editing was on point, the shots were really well-composed, and the lighting was usually very evocative.

It starts off at once mysterious and ominous, thanks to the overpowering and not-so-subtle score, but very quickly you realize that the first thirty minutes are worthless. And once it's over you realize that the last thirty minutes are worthless, and that this movie really should have been made as a 30 minute short film. It's just a good idea, not a fully-fleshed out movie. Most of the movie is pretty mediocre: simple story, missing message, unimpressive acting, worthless dialogue, uninspired music. The black and white cinematography didn't add much to the movie and was simply a cheap yet effective way of making it look prettier (albeit older). It felt odd and out of place seeing modern cars and technology in black and white. And most of the shots were also extremely minimalist, which took away from the realism. But the nail-biting tension, on par with the scenes with Christopher Walken in The Deer Hunter, is what you should see this movie for because that is all it really is. Recommended if you're interested in thrillers and suspense movies, but don't try to sniff out the plot details before watching.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0475169/

The Good German (2006)

3/5

The best part about The Good German is how it looked. A murder mystery set in 1945 post-war Berlin, it attempts to emulate a film noir style but doesn't quite succeed. The problem is that Soderbergh doesn't know film well enough, and doesn't get the specifics right. I liked how he made the film look, with his stark black and white photography and slightly blurred images, but film noir didn't look like that. While film back then was never quite as crisp as the HD cameras we have now, it was certainly more crisp than the TV-style images inhabiting this movie. And the heavy black and whites with minimal gray midtones was too stark for 40's noir; it felt more in line with the worse film grain from the mid-30's. Additionally, while noirs are supposed to have confusing, labyrinthine plots, this one is a bit excessive. At the end of the movie, I really had no idea what had happened, which is never a good thing. I understood more about The Big Sleep. It seemed as if there were a bunch of innuendos and assumptions that the characters went with that I never got, which left me in the dark for most of the movie. Also, there were so many "references" or "homages" to Casablanca, not just in shots, but in entire plot constructions, that it just felt like theft to me.

On the other side of the stick, the cinematography was amazing. The lighting and composition in so many scenes were spot-on and looked like actual 1940's film noir. The consistently bleak mood and dark underbelly of surviving in such a ravaged situation fit nicely in the noir genre. While the swearing and sex were not exactly staples of film noir, their inclusion in the movie made it feel more crude and more vulgar, which I believe is how film noir felt in the 40's. The acting was amazing by all parties. Tobey Maguire unnerved me, Cate Blanchett was equally stunning and deceptive, and George Clooney, it seemed, really would stop at nothing to get to the truth. Unfortunately, this movie is not a film noir, for a great many reasons, and despite all its efforts, it is merely an unsuccessful attempt at one. Not really recommended, but A for effort.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0452624/

July 07, 2007

A Guide to Recognizing Your Saints (2006)

3/5

A Guide to Recognizing Your Saints is the strangest film adaptation of a book I've ever seen, because it's also about what happens after the book was published. The movie centers around Dito as he comes back home to his sick father and remembers his past life experiences in the tough Astoria, Queens neighborhood of New York. As a gritty, realist coming-of-age drama, the movie works. The excess, about him coming back home after twenty years, felt worthless to me. The directing as a whole actually felt really creative, especially considering Montiel is not really a director. The editing style evoked a nostalgic mood, and most of the movie really felt like his memories, not his stories. An important sound would be remembered first, then the rest of the story. Black outs and sounds fading out at emotionally trying moments. Fuzzy audio or blurry video. All of these artistic decisions worked extremely well and made the movie much more personal to the viewer. The acting was very well done and I enjoyed it the entire time. The music also fit snugly with the mood.

Like I said, the second story about Dito coming back home felt worthless, and was especially disappointing since Robert Downey Jr. and Rosario Dawson were billed so high. Nothing physically happened at his return, nor did any emotion or sentiment that wasn't already previously expressed get uncovered. Luckily, it did not take up much of the movie. Sometimes the editing style irked me, even though I understand that that's probably how he remembered it. The shots were pretty mediocre and uninspired. I hated the font choice and usage. Some scenes felt really pointless (in the past too, not just the present). What I really hated was when he tried to copy Spike Lee and have the characters talk to the camera about "who they are." What pissed me off about it most was not that it was straight-up copying, but that it wasn't even necessary. It added nothing to the movie and only cheapened it. Overall though, I really enjoyed watching this movie and recommend it if this sounded interesting to you.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0473488/

Transformers (2007)

3/5

Transformers was a really, really fun movie. It's a summer blockbuster action movie that delivers for the entire two and a half hours. The special effects and the fights just blew me away. Some of the scenes were absolutely hilarious and had me laughing and smiling. Even though the movie was long, it was varied enough in content and mood to keep you interested and entertained. I especially loved the shout-out to Bay's earlier movie, where a kid runs around with a camera shouting, "This is so much better than Armageddon!" Also, I hear fans of the original cartoons were very pleased with how it turned out. The music was excellent and kept your blood pumping strong. The multiple storylines weave together really well.

As expected, the dialogue was extremely corny the entire time. The acting was awful. There were a ton of minor characters that were worthless (the hackers), along with subplots that were worthless (sending out a code while trapped inside). It could have easily been a much tighter, better-acted, better-written two hour movie if they had tried a little harder. Also, the main actress was pretty hot, I guess, but her face was really weird. Most of the scenes went on for too long and, at two and a half hours, the movie definitely overstayed its welcome. Although it never really got to the point where it was boring, I definitely felt some of the scenes to be quite tedious and tiring. Some of the fights were too short and there wasn't as big of a climax as I expected there to be; also, some were really confusing because of how it was shot and it was hard to tell what was going on. Also, I didn't like how the Transformers were so alien; I really didn't like their new designs. Anyway, if this movie ever interested you or you thought it might be good, go watch it, because you will not be disappointed.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0418279/

July 04, 2007

The Lives of Others (2006)

4/5

The Lives of Others is a suspense drama about surveillance in Eastern Germany before the fall of the Berlin Wall. It follows agent XX/7 as he listens in on the lives of right-wing playwright Georg Dreyman and his wife and actress Christa-Maria Sieland. The movie is excellent, but did not live up to my (somewhat high) expectations. I liked how it conveyed the emotional connection and almost unstoppable attraction between the viewer and the subject, although the metaphor does not extend very well into the actual film audience and the film itself, which I was hoping it would. The ending is surprisingly tender. The extent of XX/7's sacrifice for these people he knows so intimately yet must forever remain anonymous to was unexpected and quite moving. The cinematography was crisp, the camera movements fluid, and the editing natural. The acting and music were also good, although the dialogue and the script as a whole seemed to be trying a bit too hard to make a point.

There were also some aspects I didn't like. The first is that some parts of the movie were extremely confusing. I don't know if it was bad directing, bad subtitles, or simply that the characters' actions meant more than I saw, but I definitely missed some explanations and motivations for events in the middle of the movie. Many scenes seemed superfluous and some parts in the beginning and middle were a bit slow. There is a very bizarre scene near the beginning involving a very full-bodied prostitute, which I really did not understand at all. Also, there is a lot of talking, which means for those who don't understand German, there is a lot of reading. Overall, a very good movie and recommended to anyone who might be interested.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0405094/

July 01, 2007

Sicko (2007)

4/5

What makes me appreciate Sicko as more than a simple documentary on the American health care system is that its subject matter is in dire need of being discussed--it is both timely and topical. After taking INST 203 last semester and being exposed to all the benefits and deficits that come with our health care system, I've started thinking a lot more on the issue. And the fact of the matter is that we need to make it a national priority. Sicko, as a movie and not merely a springboard for cocktail party conversation, was quite effective. There were funny parts that kept the movie from being overly depressing and very emotional parts as well, which grounded the movie in reality. The first half of the movie I found myself fighting with facts I had learned, but the last thirty minutes or so hit you on an emotional level, where facts don't mitigate these real peoples' problems. Unlike Fahrenheit 9/11, it ended on a serious note and not a funny one--you leave the movie thinking that this is a matter that can be improved on, not something you can just laugh away and ignore. So while this movie is far from perfect, I am glad he made it and recommend it to anyone and everyone.

The movie does have a surplus of problems too. The first is that it is made by Michael Moore. He carries with him a lot of baggage and hate because of his earlier movies, and unfortunately a lot of people are not going to see this movie simply because he made it. Going in, you already know it's going to be a biased, pointed attack and not an exposé showing both sides, facts, and solutions. Which irritated me a lot. It begged for sympathy by first showing the victims of the HMOs and their health coverage denials. It claimed that the US was one of the least healthiest nations in the world, even though it pays the most for health care. It showed the perfect universal health care of Britain and France and their longer-living, healthier patients. But it ignores so much that it's almost insulting to the viewer. I don't think Europe's health rating would be as high if they had to deal with AIDS from African countries and TB in east Asian countries in equal quantities as the typical English and French diseases. And that is what the US health system must deal with every day. Being the heterogeneous melting pot that we are, the number of diseases people need treated are huge compared to the relatively small number in the homogeneous European populations. He ignores the benefits to the US health care system (we are one of the top nations when it comes to preventative medicine), but goes out of his way to show that other nations also do similar things (he always mentions when another nation has preventative health care).

And the movie gets very repetitive; we see the "perfect" Canadian system, then the "perfect" British system, the "perfect" French system, and then even the ridiculously sugar-coated "perfect" Cuban system. We get the point. And I don't think any of us are naive enough to think that their systems are perfect, even though they do have good qualities that our system lacks. The movie even feels repetitive when they have the victims tell their stories; there are just so many that each additional one adds nothing to the table except increase the number. What also bugged me a little was the use of archival footage and sixties-style songs, although they were kind of funny. Despite this movie's problems, I think it is one that must be watched and talked about and brought to the forefront of the political realm, because a change is necessary in the American health care system.

IMDb link: http://imdb.com/title/tt0386032/