
For the most part, it was truly astounding. There were some technical aspects that were a little rough around the edges. For example, some mysteries were left unanswered and some dialogue was hammy and overwrought. But for each of those small flaws, the movie made up for it tremendously. The entire plot was suspenseful and riveting and the special effects were awe-inspiring. The cinematography was absolutely phenomenal and breathtaking, the compositions luminous and stunning, and the editing brisk and lean. The acting and characterizations were a welcome step above what I expect for this genre of movie. (And the genre, by the way, is a mix of horror and disaster, not mystery and action, as I had assumed going in.)
What I like about Proyas is that he doesn't spoon-feed us answers, nor does he beat his message into our heads. He treads a fine line, but he trusts his audience to figure it out for themselves and interpret his movie in manners he may not have even considered himself. Sometimes he succeeds (Dark City and I, Robot), and sometimes he fails (The Crow), but he is willing to take the risk of making a new and different movie experience. And here he has succeeded again. Knowing was a wholly unexpected and exhilarating surprise.
IMDb link: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0448011/